Voucher school scheme fatally flawed


Over the past twenty years, Florida’s public school per pupil funding has skidded to the bottom quartile among the states. USA Today ranks Florida at 11th lowest and the numbers are getting worse, not better. In spite of this, the Florida Legislature is now pushing another series of taxpayer funded voucher schemes that move tax dollars from our neighborhood public schools to private and religious schools — some of them pretty sketchy — and all that lie beyond basic accountability, oversight, testing and accreditation.

I can’t think of a way to make this complicated: If our tax dollars are shoveled into private and religious schools, then, at the very least, accountability should follow to be certain that the taxpayers get their money’s worth. As it stands, that is not the case.

It is important to note that Florida’s private and religious voucher schools do not have to meet state standards required of our public schools. Voucher schools don’t have to hire certified teachers who graduated from an accredited college or university; they are not required to conduct background checks; they can be selective and “cherry-pick” in admissions; nor are they subjected to standardized tests that would allow parents the ability to compare voucher schools to their public counterparts; and more.

These unregulated conditions pave the way for “storefront schools” that will popup like mushrooms, enticing parents with publicly funded vouchers and slick marketing and then be gone a few years after profiting.

I understand the desire to foster choice. However, direct taxpayer subsidy as a new government-funded entitlement does open up a whole new can of worms. How does one determine if a school is “better” without comparative testing, accountability and earned accreditation? Under the conditions existing in Florida, taxpayer subsidization of religious and for profit schools opens the door for charlatans who don’t have to meet the standards required of public schools and state universities (i.e., transparency, certified personnel, accreditation, background checks, etc.).

Many Americans also argue that tax dollars should not be used to subsidize religious indoctrination, no matter the deity or dogma. They don’t want their taxes funding religious proselytization (e.g., teaching Noah’s ark as science, creating Islamic Madrasa schools, etc.). Folks don’t want to pay for that with their tax dollars. Certainly, parents can choose to inculcate a religion, but the public shouldn’t have to pay for it.

Private and parochial education might be made more available through private scholarships or through private foundations or by the churches, temples and mosques themselves. But public funds should go to public schools and not to help subsidize for-profit or parochial schools.

Like most folks, I believe that tax dollars should not go to untested and unregulated educational enterprises. Nor should it go to religious schools.

In my estimation, this “school choice” legislation creates more harm than good and is weighed-down with unintended consequences.

What is particularly odd is that if one looks up the biographies of individual legislators, one finds that the overwhelming majority attended public schools and state universities. If public schools worked for them, their parents and grandparents, then why would they turn their back on Florida’s underfunded public education system now? Why are they looking to shove Florida’s public school money into unregulated private schools? To answer those questions, voters need to follow the money and see where it goes.

Throughout modern history, investment in America’s system of public schools and universities has contributed to our nation’s greatness, including helping build the largest, expanding peacetime economy in world history.

Let us use our tax money to fix our neighborhood public schools with proper financing that approaches the national average in per pupil funding. Let us attract and retain incredible professional educators with competitive salaries, strengthen security and reassure the public that our public schools are a long-term investment in our community, state and nation.

Frank Layne Wood


Earth Day in Clermont registering voters and collecting petitions

Support the Lake County Democratic Party and local candidates. Your...

FROM THE LEFT-The Daily Commercial: There’s something ugly in America

'O'beautiful for spacious skies, for amber waves of grain, for purple...

FROM THE LEFT-The Daily Commercial: When did this become OK?

FROM THE LEFT When did this become OK? When I first learned manners as a child, I remember something that was a hard and fast rule: You don’t discuss religion or politics in polite society. Having grown up that way, I have always adhered to that strongly held belief. So what I need to know is when did this open political discourse everywhere become OK? I was sick with a migraine last week and went to a doctor for treatment. I was in the exam room with my husband and the doctor walked in and said that he was going to give me a shot to make me better, but only if I was a Republican. If I was a Democrat, he was sending me to Nancy Pelosi’s house. He was kidding. I think. But still, when did that become OK? Have we come to a moment in our history when Democrats are treated differently than Republicans? Some jokes go too far. Some jokes step over the line. So why did this doctor say such a thing? Because he thought that he could get away with it. Trump has created a new religion, furthered by his partners in crime like this doctor. If we were Republicans, we would have laughed at this “joke,” quickly and quietly reversing the entire river of knowledge, good manners, and values that we learned as children. Trump’s salvation show requires a total buy-in to his hallucinogenic spells in which he conjures up new boogeymen on a daily basis in his technicolor dreams. He then appears before the crowd spewing them forth with just the right amount of over-the-top anguish, making his followers believe at once that he is indeed the champion of their cause as the oppressed working class, while simultaneously asking them to believe that he is also the richest person ever. Oh, and really smart. Faith. You must have faith. And it is because of this blind faith and aided by people who really know better, that he gets away with his outlandish behavior. He has gotten away with it all of his life. And apparently, it is because no one has ever told him that it is not OK! We all know that he is all about putting his name on everything. He slaps his name in huge letters on the top of big buildings and golf courses everywhere and claims he built them. Last week when he went to the border to visit the mecca of his delusions – The Wall – he carried a plaque proclaiming that it was “Trump’s Wall” and had it mounted on the FENCE that was built with taxpayer money during the Obama Administration. Was that OK? There is a new book about how much Trump has cheated at golf over the years. As someone who has spent most of my career in that industry and with a husband who has maintained from day one that “If you cheat at golf, you will cheat at everything”, I was intrigued. There is a true story contained in the book about a Trump-owned golf property holding their annual club championship. Trump called to ask who had won. He told them “No. put my name on the top of the plaque as the winner” even though he didn’t play in the tournament and wasn’t even at the property. Say WHAT? When did that become OK? And no one said no? The question is, how are we supposed to teach real values to our children? How can we tell them to play by the rules or even discuss the rules when they see us idolizing someone who so clearly does not? What about manners and good sportsmanship? It has become a general “loosening of the rules” of our entire society. Well, not just a “loosening”. We have totally lost our way. His followers believe that they can do or say anything because they see him get away with it. When did that become OK? The fact is that it is not OK. While lying there sick and asking a Republican doctor to treat me, I reminded him of that. Politics should have never entered the room. No, that was definitely not OK! Mary Sharpe

FROM THE LEFT- The Daily Commercial: Electoral College as obsolete as the Three-Fifths clause

Electoral College as obsolete as the Three-Fifths clause FROM THE LEFT...

“From the Left”-The Daily Commercial: The fault is not in our stars, but in ourselves

The fault is not in our stars, but in ourselves FROM THE LEFT The self...

FROM THE LEFT- The Daily Commercial: Voucher School Scheme Fatally Flawed

Voucher school scheme fatally flawed FROM THE LEFT Over the past twenty...


Support the Lake County Democratic Party and local candidates. Your support is vital and will help us Get Out The Vote, support volunteer efforts, and help support Democratic candidates across our county.


Help make a difference! Volunteers are the life blood of the Lake Democrats. We have many volunteer opportunities that can fit your schedual and skill set.

Sign Up For Events

Use Mobilize America to sign up for local events and volunteer opportunities. Join us in making a difference today!

Join Our Mailing List

Join Our Mailing List

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news, updates, volunteer opportunities and event announcements.

You have Successfully Subscribed!